Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | SFO_SIN's commentslogin

good idea, but would've been useful 10 years ago when points and the churning game were peak.

in 2026, the optimal strategy is now:

- "want first, buy first" (pay cash when you want business class) and,

- "team cash back" for credit cards without playing the coupon book game

not worth the effort to optimize 1.5 vs 2.0 cent redemption unless it's a hobby


Nope. I just booked biz class flights to Scandinavia in August for 140k pts.

Cash was about $7k for the same flights.

In part, the reason I built this wasn't exactly to optimize 1.5cpp vs 2cpp, although that can be useful too... but rather to help me make the choice between using points vs. cash. (which, yes, is based on the cpp value).

But if you don’t find it useful, I’d love that feedback too!


> I just booked biz class flights to Scandinavia in August for 140k pts.

> Cash was about $7k for the same flights.

Cash price US$3,500

https://www.google.com/travel/flights/s/64QhvwAzsAGp8NUA7

August 5 to 12, Turkish Airlines, lie-flat business class all legs, round trip, Los Angeles to Istanbul to Oslo

points game is over, man.

but again, if it's a hobby and you like searching, winning, and finding a good deal, then sure. that has value.


Thanks for proving my point, as I was booking for 2pax, which is about $3500/pax indeed. And the 140k pts was total for both (+ ~$1200 total for fees, etc., in the interest of full disclosure).

I was booking over 3 weeks, late August to early September, and I booked on KLM/AF. I had specific date ranges I needed to hit.

Again, you don't have to like it. That's fine.

But consider that "I think points are nonsense" isn't the person this was built for. :)


> Thanks for proving my point, as I was booking for 2pax, which is about $3500/pax indeed. And the 140k pts was total for both (+ ~$1200 total for fees, etc., in the interest of full disclosure).

Again, sounds like you're trying too hard to justify 2 cpp vs 3 cpp.

Cash price $2,900/pax including fees, Aug 19 to Sep 9 (21 days), Turkish airlines lie-flat business round trip with nice short 1h30m layover at a brand new airport.

https://www.google.com/travel/flights/s/fewZVhBFrtMTn7WQ6

Versus your 70k points + $600 cash fees per person?

Especially with kids, or with high income, you stop caring about $1,000/person and care more about simplicity or having the trip vs not (e.g., departing on Friday cash vs Wednesday points)

And if one is rich with points (1 million+), then one should have no problem spending 250k points one-way business on the date of their choice. Otherwise, they can't consume their point balance.


Okay. Like I said, you don’t have to like it.

I was happy with the deal I found because my goal was saving cash, and using points I already had. I am not trying to prove a point past that.

$600/pax is a lot less than $2900/pax. Saving $4600 total to use 140k points is, indeed, very useful for me and a lot of other people.

You have other desires and needs. Cool. You could also build those into your request, but like I said: I don’t see the point you’re trying to make other than “I don’t want to like this tool because I don’t like points in general,” which is fine.

Do your thing! And I’ll do mine. :)


Related indirectly : Turkish airlines hub (Istanbul airport) is a scam. Everything there costs at least twice the price it should. Especially food which is basically what everyone does during layover. Think 30€ for a burger or a kebab.

« Brand new » is not an argument by itself. Business is a must, or at least booking a lounge.


> Turkish airlines hub (Istanbul airport) is a scam. Everything there costs at least twice the price it should. Especially food which is basically what everyone does during layover. Think 30€ for a burger or a kebab.

Business class passengers don't pay for food. They are busy eating free buffet in the lounge.


lol you conveniently left out 50% of the ticket fees

$600/pax (which I disclosed) is hardly 50% of the ticket fees, which were, as I mentioned, $3500/pax or so otherwise.

your 70k points + $600/pax is equivalent to $1300

so $600 fees is 46% of the points + cash you paid

you could've cashed out 70k points as $700, therefore the 70k points becomes cash in the math


OK, so you've calculated I've saved $2200/pax. Fine.

For the record, I already took that into account. My goal with these flights was to save cash, because at the moment, cash flow is the issue I'm solving for. At other times, I have other priorities.

I can't believe I have to say this, but... YMMV, I guess.


I don't know if US miles gives better deals, but in EU (Flying Blue, KLM) Amsterdam-Munich (1hr flight) business class is 52k miles. Amsterdam - Los Angeles business class goes for 550k miles. For 1 passenger.

This was 70k round trip SFO-OSL, for 1 passenger. In general, good deals on international flying is the main win with points. Domestic can be useful too, but usually less so.

> Nope. I just booked biz class flights to Scandinavia in August for 140k pts.

Was it 70k points for single passenger, round-trip business class?

It's usually 100k points for one-way business class.

More likely 70k is one-way. Which means 140k points round trip + $600+ fees, vs $2900 cash price, which is hardly a deal.


It was 70k/pax round trip business class.

Yes, I agree it was a great deal.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: