Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't have any experience with iOS, and haven't scripted in anger in powershell.

Linux and its ecosystem evolved alongside bash. If somebody tried to make a thing, and said thing was difficult to script with bash, nobody used the thing. They would say it's "hard to use". So system facilities and applications that don't script well with a shell script like bash (or csh or zsh to tcsh...) never survived.

Basically, everything in linux automation is a nail, and bash is a very good hammer. DOS/Windows has had .bat scripts forever, which is not a particularly good hammer, but more importantly, Windows automation is very much not-nail like. You need a wrench and a socket set for many tasks, and CMD simply doesn't do that very well. (neither does bash for that matter) So powershell is a godsend. Meanwhile, us linux folks are sitting here with our hammer and all of our nails, and ... well, while I see that sometimes, it's maaaaybe nice to have a screwdriver as well, I certainly don't see the need for powershell.

> Particularly in the recent history of "every day, another shell" on linux/mac.

You'll note that all of these shells try to be a better hammer. None of them go in the direction that powershell goes in.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: