Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The mountains of e-waste created by keeping around a zombie protocol far exceeds a transition to a widely used and accepted standard.

The majority of people with iPhone likely already have USB-C cables anyway, so requires no net new purchase



How many of those users have USB C cables capable of video over USB, USB3 speeds etc?

If the EU were going to “mandate” something, don’t be half assed about it.


I dunno, but lightning doesn’t support that anyway, so who cares?


Actually, Lightning can support USB 3. The first generation iPad Pro did.

But I thought EU was trying to prevent incompatibility?


Love seeing all the Apple zombies malding over making society convenient for people.

This legislation wouldn’t have even happened if Apple had done the right thing to begin with. Instead of trying to eek out margins on proprietary cables


Yes because out of the billions Apple makes, the few pennies that Lightning makes is really meaningful.

My issue is not the USB C mandate, it’s the usual incompetence of the EUs half way thought out laws.

If you are going to mandate a standard, mandate a good one - including minimum data transfer, power delivery and video - all parts of the standard.


I agree the law could have been written better.

It could have just enforced that vendors must use an agreed upon standard by X% of industry participants or similar. Thus if you want a competing connector, you have to propose a new standard and get buy in from others.

But the end result is the same regardless. When the need for a new standard comes, the spec will be updated or abandoned in favor of a new one.

As to Apple’s reasoning for not using USB-C, who’s to say? I would think cable revenue is minuscule at the end of the day, yet here they are still using lightning almost a decade after the rest of the industry standardized on USB-C

At their scale they need to operate in a somewhat sensible way or regulators will target them, that’s life. Society is not going to be beholden to Apple’s design choices if it negatively affects enough people




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: