Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That seems less like a reasoning issue and more an issue of building up an ASCII chart in a single pass. I doubt most humans would be able to accomplish that.

To demonstrate this a bit, I asked for HP's family tree as JSON, suitable for use in a charting library, and this is what it came up with:

---

{ "nodes": [ { "id": "Harry Potter" }, { "id": "Ginny Weasley" }, { "id": "James Potter" }, { "id": "Lily Potter (née Evans)" }, { "id": "Arthur Weasley" }, { "id": "Molly Weasley (née Prewett)" }, { "id": "Fleamont Potter" }, { "id": "Euphemia Potter" }, { "id": "Mr. Evans" }, { "id": "Mrs. Evans" }, { "id": "Vernon Dursley" }, { "id": "Petunia Dursley (née Evans)" }, { "id": "Dudley Dursley" }, { "id": "James Sirius Potter" }, { "id": "Albus Severus Potter" }, { "id": "Lily Luna Potter" } ], "links": [ { "source": "Harry Potter", "target": "James Potter" }, { "source": "Harry Potter", "target": "Lily Potter (née Evans)" }, { "source": "Ginny Weasley", "target": "Arthur Weasley" }, { "source": "Ginny Weasley", "target": "Molly Weasley (née Prewett)" }, { "source": "James Potter", "target": "Fleamont Potter" }, { "source": "James Potter", "target": "Euphemia Potter" }, { "source": "Lily Potter (née Evans)", "target": "Mr. Evans" }, { "source": "Lily Potter (née Evans)", "target": "Mrs. Evans" }, { "source": "Petunia Dursley (née Evans)", "target": "Mr. Evans" }, { "source": "Petunia Dursley (née Evans)", "target": "Mrs. Evans" }, { "source": "Vernon Dursley", "target": "Petunia Dursley (née Evans)" }, { "source": "Dudley Dursley", "target": "Vernon Dursley" }, { "source": "Dudley Dursley", "target": "Petunia Dursley (née Evans)" }, { "source": "James Sirius Potter", "target": "Harry Potter" }, { "source": "James Sirius Potter", "target": "Ginny Weasley" }, { "source": "Albus Severus Potter", "target": "Harry Potter" }, { "source": "Albus Severus Potter", "target": "Ginny Weasley" }, { "source": "Lily Luna Potter", "target": "Harry Potter" }, { "source": "Lily Luna Potter", "target": "Ginny Weasley" } ] }

---

Sorry about HN formatting, but you get the idea. This looks fairly accurate to me. What about this demonstrates less "reasoning" then turning it into an ASCII chart?



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: