Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is very well written and the last paragraph really drives home what a disaster this is


Seem needlessly harsh to humans, is there some less hubristic animal? The other animals don't even know the word, and they'd pave over rivers too if they even were capable of having bad ideas, I mean it's not like beavers or termites are exercising wise restraint.


Beavers are arguably beneficial to the bigger picture in their area, they don't make concreate waterways, they make large shallow lakes with lots of boggy areas.

Hellish for humans to walk about and navigate, sure.

Very good for temperature stabilisations, wetland life, water retention in areas that would otherwise drain and dry out, etc.


Beavers completely monopolize the area, if they can. They literally drown their competition.

That has pluses and minuses.

For one, it’s really terrible living in an area that beavers insist on turning into swamps, if you don’t prefer swamps.

Having some swamps somewhere, does help nature though.

Just like it’s terrible not having a roof over your head, or getting flooded out.

Having some flooding somewhere is good for nature though.

Prior generations optimized for getting housing in place quickly and cheaply, and having predictable flooding behavior even if it looked ugly.

And they got it.

What should we optimize for now?

pick your poison. Pros/cons, etc.


Also arguably bad in some places they're edging out the locals (South America) or contributing to greenhouse gas emissions (the warming Arctic), if you believe in "invasive species" (some people don't)


Definitely, beavers are excellent, but not on purpose. When we say "human hubris" we're thinking of ourselves as bad for being able to think of things. Bacteria, by comparison, cause less havoc, but that's because their activities are limited by what's evolutionarily adaptive. They caused a mass extinction once, but that was a couple of billion years ago. None of the other creatures are being deliberately good. Neither are humans, on the whole, but at least it troubles our minds sometimes.


> and they'd pave over rivers too if they even were capable of having bad ideas

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vacuous_truth

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: