Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

One big difference with the Middle East is that the present day borders were largely drawn up by foreign powers (England, France) rather than evolving organically as they did in post-Roman Europe. This is also a source of much of the ongoing conflicts in the region including Israel/Palestine.


That's one of the big points made in 'A Peace to End all Peace', I just felt my comment was too long as is. Here's how Fromkin puts it, edited down for length:

Some of the disputes, like those elsewhere in the world, are about rulers or frontiers, but what is typical of the Middle East is that more fundamental claims are also advanced, drawing into question not merely the dimensions and boundaries, but the right to exist, of countries that immediately or eventually emerged from the British and French decisions of the early 1920s: Iraq, Israel, Jordan, and Lebanon.

...

The disputes go deeper still: ... whether the transplanted modern system of politics invented in Europe—characterized, among other things, by the division of the earth into independent secular states based on national citizenship—will survive in the foreign soil of the Middle East. In the rest of the world European political assumptions are so taken for granted that nobody thinks about them anymore; but at least one of these assumptions, the modern belief in secular civil government, is an alien creed in a region most of whose inhabitants, for more than a thousand years, have avowed faith in a Holy Law that governs all of life, including government and politics.


> rather than evolving organically as they did in post-Roman Europe

You think the borders left after Rome fell were organic? They just used the old Roman province borders. Rome replaced the rule of every country it conquered and the conquest lasted so long that there was no trace of the old rule left, they all had to rediscover themselves afterwards, including figuring out how to redraw the borders.


TBF, England and France took hundreds of years drawing up their own borders between each other


Yes but they were active participants in that process (through wars, treaties, etc). It’s not like Russia came in, took a map, drew some lines, and gave France to the Bourbons and England to the Plantagenets.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: