Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Remember though, China is still a totalitarian dictatorship at least as bad as the USA. It's not the same situation.


I don't think we'll see born-in-the-USA Americans moving to Shenzhen anytime soon.

But a huge fraction of our workforce is immigrants who have given up their homeland and distanced themselves from their families and communities in search of opportunities here. The fact that we're driving them away now does not bode well for our future economy.


You should visit Shenzhen. Plenty of born-in-the-USA Americans (+ European etc) there.


If the immigrants that we've allowed to come here are so fickle that they would leave for China if China presents better opportunities, I would prefer that they leave now and get it over with. My country is not an economic zone for extracting value. It's my home.


> extracting value

Did you mean creating wealth?

I'm not talking about land speculation. I'm talking about creating businesses and jobs for everyone. I'm talking about hard labor that's necessary for our society to run. We're not better off picking crops while China's tech economy becomes #1.


A lot of immigrant communities actually voted for Donald Trump this time though. I don’t understand it. But it happened.



If someone said "Americans do X", there would be some pushback about "not all Americans". But somehow it's normal (expected even) to bunch all immigrants together into the "they were all desperate and decided to jump the fence" pile.

It's actually surprising that this point is so hard to understand.


It is very simple. Nobody hates queue jumpers more than the people that stood in line.


Those who stood in line as you say also want to take people out of today's queue. Legality doesn't have much to do with it. In Britain it's called pulling up the drawbridge.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drawbridge_mentality


> It's not the same situation.

Yet. It is not even two months in, we have not seen nothing yet.


I think a more practical framing is to ask what you enjoy doing in the US that you wouldn’t be able to do in China.

As a practical matter, the things that affected me the most when I traveled are the great firewall, language barriers, and time zone issues.

For example, I don’t protest the government. If that was an important part of my life China would be a bad choice.

Probably another question you might ask is what are the things you’d be able to do in China that you wouldn’t in the US.


Out of the two, now China seems to benefit from keeping global peace more, since USA is checking out from global trade with tariffs.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: