Not to get into pedantics, but just to offer a helpful explanation, I think it's because you used "should" instead of "would". It's no big deal, but in your sentence, should implies reasonable, while would implies expected. (Even though should also has a usage where it means expected, that's only when you're unsure of something happening in the future, whereas this event has already happened.)
I hate being right. I remember years ago predicting that if MAGA got back in they’d levy a huge tax increase they’d call a tax cut and a huge spending increase they’d call a spending cut.
My other big prediction for years has been that it’ll be MAGA that will do mass gun confiscation in defiance of the second amendment. Let’s see how that one does. Of course all the MAGA folks would be fine with it because it's not mass gun confiscation by the "new world order" if Trump does it.
