Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Your robo taxis will also become dirty, unsafe and unclean.

The quality of service a private entity will provide, does not magically make it better.

It’s better only because of competition driving differentiation in order to capture more market share.

But if you cannot compete further on quality, you will compete on price.

The airline industry is a good example of this.

Public Safety, public transit, can be very good, provided the incentives, funding and institutions to serve it are funded.

People take pride in their work, including the work that results in world quality public services.



How will the robotaxis become unsafe? The reason public transit is unsafe is because of the other passengers on board with you, but you have the robotaxi to yourself.


> How will the robotaxis become unsafe?

Apparently they already are: they need a supervisor human for every ride.


Are Waymos unsafe too? Didn't they also have them at first?


My point was that the robotaxis have to become safe before we can think of them becoming unsafe again :-). I don't remember mentioning Waymo.


They already aren't safe


Pricing - the point of the airline industry example is to highlight the level of nickel and diming that happens.

I’ve been on the best ranked airline, and had dirty toilets - before take off.

I’m not alluding to enshittification here - just that if your commuters don’t have the money to pay for better quality taxis, they are going to get dirtier cabs, and less safer cars.

Being private isn’t a magic bullet- it’s a matching of incentives and markets that produces outcomes.

This doesn’t mean that public goods and services can’t be equivalently good.


But when people complain public transit is unsafe, they don't mean that it's dirty (even though that's usually also true). They specifically mean they're worried about being the victim of a crime committed by someone else on it with them, and robotaxis solve that regardless of price.


There was a gang operation in India that targeted drivers stuck in traffic.

They tapped on the side of the car, making it seem like there had been an impact.

When the driver opened their window and leaned out to find out what would happen, they grabbed whatever was on the windshield and ran.

Automated cars have been stopped by … consecutive stop signs.

Look - Safety is - at some point - a societal issue. Yes, being in your own taxi is cool, and the threat you are concerned about is reduced.

But this is assuming things remain the same.


I have never seen an airplane anywhere near as filthy as nearly every subway I've been on.


I did. Long haul flights are always yummy. And the toilets there are just the cherry on the top.


Airplanes are dirty, unsafe and unclean?


The robotaxis will have someone cleaning them between uses? Maybe they can sit in the front seat!


By letting people report messes in the taxi that arrives and passing on the vehicle if it’s soiled, then you can quickly determine and evict the messy people from the system.


Airplanes usually have crews cleaning them after every flight + crew keeping order during the flight. Have you ever seen an airplane which just landed after 12 hours flight? What a mess huh?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: