Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Like I said, you're cherry-picking. You believe some of what the Iranians say, and not the rest. You believe some of what Trump says, but not the rest.

And you do care what Trump says, since you're buying his bogus, self-contradicting justification for going to war with Iran.

Iran wasn't a threat to the US.

Edit: that 2022 interview you quoted from an Iranian not affiliated to any nuclear program or knowledgeable about it, and which later recanted/clarified it, has problems to say the least. Another example of cherry-picking. I'm not surprised it has since been amplified by Trump (a person whose opinion you don't care about) and by various Israeli news outlets.

 help



So you claim that this high ranking Iranian government official was lying?

Judging from what I've read, he claims that's not what he was saying, and that it was his personal opinion at the time since he wasn't involved in any nuclear program. You're latching to one person's words, since recanted/corrected, because it helps the narrative you like: cherry-picking.

More importantly, do you claim Trump was lying? (I do, to be clear, but do you?).

Let me repeat it because this is important: Iran posed no threat to the US.


[flagged]


I'm not an expert. Probably anti Western sentiment, anti any former allies of the deposed Shah, and pro Palestinian sentiment.

But in reality this doesn't matter, because you're now moving the goalposts: I didn't argue that Iran wasn't hostile to Israel.

I claimed that Iran's nuclear program was already destroyed for 10+ years (mission success, as claimed last year with total certainty by Trump), and that Iran didn't pose a threat to the US.

Now, if the US wants to fight Israel's wars, that's cool and dandy, but the majority of Americans don't support this. Remember "America First"?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: